Monday, May 21, 2012
Melendez v tThompson III and bad judging in MMA with added eye pokes
I'm not really happy with the way Melendez v Thompson III went down. Not necessarily that Melenedez won - I expected that, indeed, I expected Melendez to dominate Thompson but that is far from what happened because I thought Thompson won that fight (so did one judge). But because Thompson got eye poked three times
In Melendez's corner was Jake Shields, who in his fight with Georges St-Pierre, poked GSP at least five times. After the third round, you can clearly hear GSP in the corner saying, "I can't see out of my left eye." By the end of the fight, he couldn't see much out of his right eye, either.
So, here's the frustrating part: how often does a guy have to get poked in the eye before a ref takes a point off? And why are people who train with Jake Shields such eye gouging bastards? (I can't really blame Cesar Gracie, as much as I might want to. The Diaz brothers don't do eye pokes.)
This is a serious issue, way worse than nearly any other foul in MMA, because of the fragility of eyes. But for lesser fouls, points would be deducted. The third time you kick a dude in the nuts? They're taking a point. Same for cage holding, or holding the other guy's shorts or whatever. With any other foul, three times is almost always when they take away a point. But in Melendez v Thompson III, Gil poked Thompson three times and the ref gave Gil a warning after the third poke.
To add insult to injury, after none of these eye pokes did the ring doctor come out and make sure, y'know, that Thompson's eyes were okay. It's hard not to regard ring-side doctors as being somewhere below junkie whores in terms of trustworthiness. Still, this is their fucking job. It's an important job, because no fighter admits to being unable to fight. (So, for instance, in the very next fight, Josh Barnett broke his hand in the first round and kept fighting for four more rounds. GSP did not even alert anyone but his corner to the fact he was blind in one eye. Toughness is a prized trait among fighters, they are usually unwilling to admit to any weakness. Which is why we have these doctors, right?)
That's disgraceful. Just disgraceful.